OPINION
LOCKDOWN WITHOUT PLAN
Treating migrants with compassion is the least the government can do
- VIPIN PUBBY
Treating migrants with compassion is the least the government can do




There are some visuals from the post-Independent India which would forever remained etched in our collective conscious and would cause all sane persons to hang their heads in shame.

The first such images were the trudging of millions of people, including women, children and the infirm, across the newly created border between India and Pakistan carrying whatever belongings they could salvage and the gruesome violence that left thousands dead. Then there were visuals of victims of Bhopal gas leak tragedy, massacre of Sikhs in Delhi and elsewhere, violence in the wake of demolition of the Babri Masjid in Ayodhya and brutal attack on Muslims in Gujarat after a railway compartment at Godhra was put on fire which led to the death of Hindu pilgrims returning from Ayodhya.

The latest visuals for which we must hang our heads as a nation are those of thousands of poor migrants, including women, children and the infirm, walking hundreds of miles to reach their homes after the four hour notice for a national lockdown in the wake of coronavirus outbreak.

With no jobs, no roof, no money in their pockets and a vast majority having families including small children in their villages, it is one of the worst crisis that have befallen these unfortunate ones. Undoubtedly coronavirus has unleashed the biggest ever human tragedy of epic proportions.

It is evident that the government just forgot about the plight of millions of daily wage earners who subsisted from hand to mouth. Neither was there any reference for them in the prime minister Narendra Modi’s address to the nation, nor did the state governments pay any attention to their plight for the next four days. It was only after a hue and cry was raised by a section of media that the governments woke up. Public buses were provided to take them to shelter homes and arrangements were made for their food. Yet again, the governments did little to look after the families of many of these migrants which subsequently led to unrest among such migrants.

Ironically the government sent special aircrafts to get back its citizens stranded abroad but let lakhs of migrants walk for miles and did not provide public transport to take them home.

But the discrimination against the poor unorganised labour and daily wagers did not end there. While several of them faced lathi charge for demanding to go back home, some of the state governments have sent special buses to ferry pilgrims and tourists who were similarly stranded.

The latest example of stark discrimination is the provision of hundreds of buses sent by Yogi Adityanath’s government in Uttar Pradesh to Kota in Rajasthan to ferry back students stranded in the town. Of these buses could be sent to Kota to bring home students, why is this not being done for migrants wanting to reach home.

BJP spokespersons offered no explanation for such discrimination. They had none. It is obvious that the government came under pressure of the students who had launched a social media campaign while the poor and voice-less migrants were not that capable to do so. Yet they held hopes for an early return to their homes. The decision to extend the lockdown, which appears to be justified, for another 19 days led to some of these people losing patience. This led to unrest in places like Mumbai, Surat, Vijayawada and Pune.

Interviews with a wide section of such section of society has revealed that while some complain of inadequate food or improper arrangements for stay, most have the thoughts of their families back in villages who have been left to fend for themselves.

It is certainly a genuine concern and a matter that needs to be addressed by the governments both at the central and state levels. As a first step the governments must ensure that all poor and needy must get adequate rations whether they have ration cards or not or whether they fall under one or the other categories of poor as per government classifications. Each citizen must be ensured adequate rations and a little subsistence allowance.

Our granaries are overflowing with stocks of wheat and rice. In fact a huge amount of stocks get damaged due to leakages or are eaten up by rats and other pests each year. As per reports, the government has a total food stock of 71 million metric tonnes while the national requirement of minimum stock is 22 million metric tonnes. In addition, the rabbi crop is ready for harvesting and thanks to the farmers in Punjab, Haryana and adjoining states, the days of shortage of foodgrains are long over. One of the food experts said during a televised debate that even if the government was to distribute free rations to all the poor, without the need of a ration card, the total outflow would be only 20 million metric tonnes.

This is the time for the government to open up all the surplus stocks and be liberal in distributing the ration free to the needy. It can depend on the hardy farmers, even though they themselves are facing serious crisis for harvesting and selling their crop, to make up for the losses. Farmers too should be provided adequate facilities and liberal loans to tide over the current crisis.

When union minister for food and public distribution Ram Bilas Paswan was confronted with questions on the central government sitting over huge stocks of foodgrains, he simply side stepped the questions and made no commitment for release to mitigate the sufferings of the poor.

Watch video

And while government certainly needs to do more to meet the needs of the poor and the stranded migrants, each one of us also needs to put our best foot forward to help out our countrymen.

Government agencies in certain areas are doing good work and have taken cooperation of local citizens, social and welfare organisations and religious groups to reach out to the needy. Many of them have formed WhatsApp groups which include government officials concerned and prominent citizens where notes about requirements and distribution of free food or dry rations are exchanged. Some of them are doing a wonderful and commendable job.

This is perhaps more true of regions like Punjab and Haryana, where residents have reached out to the needy and are providing them food and other basic requirements.
 
Punjabis, and particularly the Sikhs, are always known to be extra generous in feeding and taking care of those in need. Several Sikh organisations are infact organising langars not only in several parts of the country but even abroad. I’m also aware of several families who had transformed their kitchens into community kitchens for preparing food on a large scale for distribution. Perhaps that could be one reason why there are no or few reports of unrest in the north part of India as compared to the west including Maharashtra.

All it is necessary that those more fortunate ones must donate generously to such social organisations and government agencies like the Red Cross to contribute to their efforts to  reach out to the needy.
------------
------------
The poor and the migrants now stranded in various parts of the country also need generous amount of compassion and help both from the other citizens and the government. While breaking laws by them is not excusable, it is also important for the government to be act with them in a more humane manner.

 

*(The author, a freelance journalist, is a former Resident Editor of Indian Express, Chandigarh, and reported on the political developments in Jammu and Kashmir, North-Eastern India, Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Haryana and Punjab in his long, illustrious career.) 

 

 

 


Watch video:


 

Disclaimer : PunjabToday.in and other platforms of the Punjab Today group strive to include views and opinions from across the entire spectrum, but by no means do we agree with everything we publish. Our efforts and editorial choices consistently underscore our authors' right to the freedom of speech. However, it should be clear to all readers that individual authors are responsible for the information, ideas or opinions in their articles, and very often, these do not reflect the views of PunjabToday.in or other platforms of the group. Punjab Today does not assume any responsibility or liability for the views of authors whose work appears here.

_______________________________________________________________

Most shared Punjab Today articles:

 

KYUN KE HUM HAIN HINDUSTANI

Three Women of 1984

 FROM 1984 TO BARGARI - Hurt & angry, we’ve tried rage, anger. Did we miss karuna?   

REVISITING 1984 – RIOT AROUND A POLE     

KARTARPUR SAHIB: A CLARION CALL FOR PEACE IN AN AGE OF CYNICISM

If it could happen to Arun Shourie, imagine what could they do to you?

Healers & Predators – The Doctor is In, & is very corrupt

Amarinder, Badals, AAP — Every party in Punjab is now an Akali Dal

Welcome to 1947. Happy Independence Day. Would you like to step out?

In Pakistan, a donkey pays for democracy – bleeding, its nostrils ripped apart

WOOING THE PANTH: Amarinder a little less Congressy, Akali Dal a little more saffron

"Captain Amarinder Singh ji” and "Rahul”: Reading Sign Language In A Relationship

The Comrade In Punjab - Lost, Irrelevant, Asleep, Even Bored!

WATERS ROYALTY - The Loot that Rajasthan Committed

AMARINDER GOVT's LOVE FOR FARMERS, AND MY DAD's FOR HIS SCOOTER

OF SUNNY KID & HORSE SENSE: The Punjab-Punjab Ties  

TRUDEAU VISIT AND RIGHT-WING MEDIA MACHINE         

 OF NIRMAL SINGH'S EYES 

Mr. CHIEF MINISTER, PLEASE CALL OFF JANUARY 7 FUNCTION         

MR PRESIDENT, PLEASE TAKE BACK HIS GALLANTRY MEDAL       

A SAFFRON JOURNEY VIA CANADA

BAD, BAD WOMAN!

 


 

_______________________________________________________________

Punjab Today believes in serious, engaging, narrative journalism at a time when mainstream media houses seem to have given up on long-form writing and news television has blurred or altogether erased the lines between news and slapstick entertainment. We at Punjab Today believe that readers such as yourself appreciate cerebral journalism, and would like you to hold us against the best international industry standards. Brickbats are welcome even more than bouquets, though an occasional pat on the back is always encouraging. Good journalism can be a lifeline in these uncertain times worldwide. You can support us in myriad ways. To begin with, by spreading word about us and forwarding this reportage. Stay engaged.

— Team PT








Comment by: Reema Anand

I agree with Mr Pubby in most of the points he has raised. The homework done by the Centre was never complete;,the percentage of migrant labour has never been completely studied, hence no ration cards issued, no Jan Khatas opened. Therefore there is no provision for ration or transportation at such times. A complete mapping of the country’s workforce needs to be done at the grassroot level.
Again, if the Prime Minister had developed the habit of a democratic approach to running the nation, he would have kept his feeder channels open. Never too late!
Even now if he wants India back on his feet, he should be panellising top economists who have handled public and private sectors. Fair exchange of thoughts and brainstorming is needed.

reply


Comment by: Dr Stanley Adrian

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

Are you interested in selling one of your k1dney for a good amount of 14Cr,( 7cr Advance ) kindly Contact
Dr. Stanley Adrian.
Whats-App No +919663960578
Call us on +919663960578

reply


Comment by: HEALTH CARE

We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.




We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.






We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.





We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.



We are urgently in need of Organs Donors, Kidney donors,Female Eggs,Kidney donors Amount: $500.000.00 Dollars
Female Eggs Amount: $500,000.00 Dollars
WHATSAP: +91 91082 56518
Email: : customercareunitplc@gmail.com
Please share this post.

reply


Comment

your name*

email address*

comments*
You may use these HTML tags:<p> <u> <i> <b> <strong> <del> <code> <hr> <em> <ul> <li> <ol> <span> <div>

verification code*
 







MOST VISITED
YOU MAY LIKE

TOPIC CLOUD

TAGS CLOUD

ARCHIVE



Copyright © 2016-2017







NEWS LETTER